Top Retirement Plan Mistakes Nonprofits Make — And How to Fix Them

top-retirement-plan-mistakes-nonprofits-make-and-how-to-fix-them

Top Retirement Plan Mistakes Nonprofits Make—And How to Fix Them

Retirement plans are essential for recruiting and retaining high-quality talent in nonprofits. Yet many organizations unintentionally mismanage their 401(a), 403(b), 457(b), or 457(f) plans simply because they lack the internal bandwidth, specialized knowledge, or governance structure needed to oversee them. These mistakes can increase plan costs, reduce employee participation, and expose the organization to legal risk.

The good news is that most retirement plan issues in the nonprofit sector can be fixed with proper oversight, annual benchmarking, and clear communication. This guide explains the most common retirement plan mistakes nonprofits make and how to address them before they turn into compliance, financial, or reputational problems.

1. Not Reviewing Plan Fees Regularly

One of the biggest mistakes nonprofits make is failing to benchmark plan fees. Recordkeepers, custodians, and investment providers often increase fees over time, and many nonprofits do not realize how much they are paying annually or whether those fees are reasonable for their plan size.

Why This Matters

High fees directly reduce employees’ retirement savings. Even a small fee difference can reduce a long-term retirement balance by tens of thousands of dollars.

How to Fix It

  • Conduct a full fee benchmarking analysis every 2–3 years
  • Request transparent fee disclosures from all providers
  • Compare plan fees to national nonprofit benchmarks
  • Move to lower-cost share classes whenever possible

Organizations with smaller plans may benefit from pooled pricing or a vendor that specializes in nonprofits.

2. Outdated or Noncompliant Plan Documents

Many nonprofits operate with plan documents that have not been updated in years, even though IRS and Department of Labor rules change frequently.

Why This Matters

Outdated documents can trigger compliance failures, IRS correction requirements, expensive legal reviews, or even plan disqualification in the worst cases.

How to Fix It

  • Review plan documents every year
  • Ensure documents align with operational practices
  • Update service agreements when switching providers
  • Keep all amendments organized and accessible for audits

Nonprofits should also ensure their Summary Plan Descriptions accurately reflect how the plan currently operates.

3. Poor Fiduciary Governance or No Formal Committee

Many nonprofits lack a formal retirement plan committee or rely entirely on one executive or HR director to oversee the plan without proper training.

Why This Matters

Retirement plans require regular monitoring, documentation, investment oversight, and fiduciary decision-making. Without structure, decisions become inconsistent, undocumented, or reactive.

How to Fix It

  • Establish a Retirement Plan Committee
  • Assign clear fiduciary roles and responsibilities
  • Create a decision-making framework and committee charter
  • Hold quarterly or biannual meetings
  • Document all discussions and decisions

This structure protects the organization and improves long-term outcomes.

4. Lack of Employee Education and Communication

Another major mistake is assuming employees understand their retirement benefits. Many nonprofit workers are unfamiliar with financial terminology or unaware of how to access their benefits.

Why This Matters

Low education leads to lower participation rates, poor investment decisions, employee frustration, and missed employer contributions.

How to Fix It

  • Offer annual employee workshops and Q&A sessions
  • Provide financial wellness resources and basic education
  • Create clear written guides and FAQs
  • Schedule one-on-one meetings during open enrollment

Education should be tailored to your workforce, including multilingual or accessible materials if needed.

5. Not Coordinating Multiple Plans

Many nonprofit organizations offer multiple retirement plans, especially those with executive teams, faculty, or highly compensated employees. Poor coordination between 401(a), 403(b), 401(k), 457(b), and 457(f) plans can cause confusion.

Why This Matters

Mismatched plans can create overlapping or conflicting benefits, inconsistent or unfair vesting schedules, excessive employer costs, and compliance risk.

How to Fix It

  • Evaluate every plan together, not in isolation
  • Align vesting, contributions, and eligibility rules
  • Coordinate benefits for executives versus broad staff
  • Ensure 457(b) and 457(f) plans follow IRS rules

A unified strategy ensures each plan serves a distinct purpose aligned with mission, budget, and workforce needs.

top-retirement-plan-mistakes-nonprofits-make-and-how-to-fix-them

6. Offering an Uncompetitive or Confusing Investment Menu

Some nonprofits offer too many investment options, outdated target-date funds, or complex choices employees do not understand.

Why This Matters

Too many options overwhelm employees and lower participation. Poorly structured menus also expose the organization to fiduciary risk if funds are not monitored.

How to Fix It

  • Simplify the investment lineup
  • Offer current, low-cost target-date funds
  • Review investment performance on a regular schedule
  • Remove redundant or high-fee funds
  • Create an investment policy statement if one does not exist

A clean, modern investment lineup supports stronger employee outcomes.

7. Missing Key Deadlines or Failing to Audit Providers

Nonprofits sometimes overlook annual filings, required testing, or service provider evaluations because internal teams are stretched thin.

Why This Matters

Missed deadlines can result in penalties, corrective filings, auditor findings, and reputational damage.

How to Fix It

  • Maintain a compliance calendar with all key dates
  • Assign responsibilities clearly across HR, finance, and leadership
  • Require annual reporting from all vendors
  • Conduct independent provider reviews as needed

A nonprofit retirement consultant can help manage deadlines and oversight if internal teams are overwhelmed.

8. Failing to Benchmark Executive Compensation Benefits

Executive compensation, including 457(b), 457(f), and supplemental executive retirement plans, must meet standards of reasonable compensation for tax-exempt organizations.

Why This Matters

Without benchmarking, benefits may appear excessive, IRS scrutiny may increase, donor trust may weaken, and public perception may suffer.

How to Fix It

  • Conduct annual compensation and benefits studies
  • Document market comparisons and peer data
  • Clearly tie benefits to strategic goals and performance
  • Ensure vesting rules meet IRS standards and are well documented

Transparency protects both the organization and its leadership team.

9. Not Reviewing Vendor Performance or Shopping for Better Services

Some nonprofits stay with the same provider for years because switching seems difficult or time-consuming.

Why This Matters

Vendors may charge outdated prices, provide poor service, offer limited technology, or fail to provide proper reporting and support.

How to Fix It

  • Review vendor performance annually
  • Conduct requests for proposals every few years
  • Compare pricing, technology, and service models
  • Ask providers for alternative share classes and lower-fee options

Your plan deserves modern tools, transparent pricing, and strong support for both staff and leadership.

10. Assuming Small Nonprofits Do Not Need Professional Oversight

Many small or mid-sized nonprofits believe their plan is too small to require expert guidance or outside consulting.

Why This Is a Mistake

Nonprofits face the same fiduciary responsibilities as large institutions. They have the same potential risks and the same need for governance, even if their plan is smaller.

How to Fix It

  • Partner with a nonprofit retirement consultant when possible
  • Use providers that specialize in small and mid-sized nonprofit plans
  • Automate processes where possible to reduce workload
  • Consider pooled employer arrangements or group pricing if available

Even small organizations benefit significantly from professional oversight and structured governance.

top-retirement-plan-mistakes-nonprofits-make (2)

How to Choose the Right Retirement Plan Consultant for Your Nonprofit

A qualified nonprofit retirement consultant should have experience with 401(a), 403(b), 401(k), 457(b), and 457(f) plan design and compliance, as well as executive compensation strategy, fiduciary governance, investment selection, fee benchmarking, and employee communication.

Ask for case studies, references, and examples of how they support organizations similar in size and mission to yours. The right partner will help you reduce risk, improve participation, and align benefits with your overall mission and budget.

Learn More About Retirement Plan Rules

For general background and IRS regulations, you can review the IRS resource on retirement plan types: IRS: Types of Retirement Plans.

Final Thoughts: A Proactive Approach Protects Your Organization

Nonprofits face unique challenges, including limited budgets, small HR teams, grant-dependent funding, and the pressure to remain compliant and mission-aligned. With proper oversight, your retirement plan can become one of your strongest recruitment, retention, and employee-wellness tools.

By identifying and correcting common mistakes, nonprofits can strengthen fiduciary governance, reduce unnecessary fees, boost employee participation, improve executive compensation transparency, lower risk, and build a competitive, resilient benefits package.

A thoughtful approach ensures your retirement plan supports your mission and your people today and long into the future.

Table of Contents

Share on:
Facebook
Pinterest
WhatsApp

Table of Contents